Italy Fines Meta $887 Million for Accessing Android Users' Photos Without Consent

Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, announced Saturday that it fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited 805 million euros, about 887 million dollars, for accessing Android users' photos and videos without obtaining specific consent. The authority said a Facebook app feature called "Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook" pulled photographs, videos and related metadata from users' phone galleries to suggest content they might want to post, without properly informing the roughly 20 million affected Android users in Italy or getting their explicit permission. The agency said the feature violated a European Union privacy directive incorporated into Italian law, which treats smartphone content as part of a person's private sphere requiring "free and informed consent."

Under the order, Meta has 60 days to turn the feature off by default and to seek separate, explicit consent before it can operate again. The fine amounts to roughly 0.47 percent of Meta's global revenue, which totaled $201 billion in 2025. The Garante said Meta's "lack of cooperation" during the investigation, which began in 2025, factored into the size of the penalty. The investigation did not examine whether the gallery content was used to train artificial intelligence models, a use the authority said Meta denied.

A Meta spokesperson said the company plans to appeal, calling the fine "disproportionate" and arguing that users already grant photo access through Android's own device-level permission system, which they can revoke at any time. The authority said it is separately reviewing a newer 2026 feature that processes gallery content in the cloud. Meta has faced repeated privacy fines from European regulators in recent years, including smaller penalties from Italian authorities over unrelated matters.

What supporters say:

  • Photo galleries contain some of the most personal content on a phone, and EU law requires specific, informed consent beyond a general operating-system permission.

  • The Garante said Meta didn't fully cooperate with the investigation, which supporters say warrants a larger penalty than a routine compliance fix.

  • Meta has been fined by European regulators multiple times before, and supporters argue repeat violations call for penalties serious enough to change behavior.

What critics say:

  • Users already grant photo access at the Android permission level and can revoke it anytime, so critics argue requiring a second layer of consent is redundant.

  • The investigation found no evidence the gallery data was used to train AI models, removing what would have been the more serious privacy concern.

  • A fine equal to under half a percent of Meta's global revenue is unlikely to change company behavior, making the enforcement largely symbolic.

What's your take?

Was Italy's $887 million fine against Meta justified? Yes ↑ No ↓ Other ◇

Sources:

#Meta #Privacy #DataProtection #Facebook #EU


Now let's hear from you.

  • You get one Take and 3 ratings so use them well.

  • Strong arguments beat loud ones. See Moving The Needle (How to)

  • Don't forget to rate your own Take.

  • Please don't feed the trolls.

About Square One

lvl-nope
@lvl-nope↓

People already agreed to let Facebook see their photos when they hit allow on their phone. Regulators keep inventing new consent hoops for American tech companies to jump through and calling it protection.